Equivalent Uniform Annual Cost with Unequal Lives
When two alternatives have different lives, convert each to an equivalent annual cost so they are compared on the same basis.
Problem
A contractor must choose one of two concrete mixers. Either machine can be replaced by an identical one at the end of its life, and the interest rate is 8% per year compounded annually. Mixer A costs $48,000, lasts 6 years, has a $6,000 salvage value and costs $7,000 per year to operate. Mixer B costs $30,000, lasts 4 years, has a $3,000 salvage value and costs $10,500 per year to operate.
The lower-cost mixer and its equivalent uniform annual cost are most nearly:
- Mixer A, $14,000 per year
- Mixer A, $18,200 per year
- Mixer A, $16,600 per year
- Mixer B, $15,600 per year
Answer
Show stepsHide steps
Given
- i = 8% per year
- Mixer A: P = $48,000, S = $6,000, n = 6 yr, C = $7,000/yr
- Mixer B: P = $30,000, S = $3,000, n = 4 yr, C = $10,500/yr
Step 1: Interest factors (4 decimals)
Step 2: EUAC of each mixer
Mixer A is cheaper by about $2,300 per year, so it is the better choice.
Check: repeat both over a common 12-year life
The 12-year least-common-multiple present worths give the same annual costs (using exact factors instead of 4-decimal ones changes the results by under $1).
Concept
The equivalent uniform annual cost (EUAC) spreads all cash flows of an alternative into one uniform yearly amount at the interest rate . Because the amount is per year, alternatives with different lives can be compared directly, assuming each can be repeated with the same costs.
- The first cost is converted with the capital recovery factor .
- The salvage value is received at the end of life, so it is converted with the sinking fund factor and subtracted.
- Annual operating cost is already uniform and is added as is.
Key Formulas
Notation: P = first cost, S = salvage value, C = uniform annual operating cost, i = interest rate per year, n = life in years. Choose the alternative with the lower EUAC.
Common Mistakes
- (A) $14,000: dividing the net first cost by the life, (48,000 - 6,000)/6 + 7,000. This ignores interest, so it understates the cost.
- (B) $18,200: adding the salvage value instead of subtracting it. Salvage is money received, so it reduces the annual cost.
- (D) Mixer B, $15,600: comparing present worths over unequal lives (B looks cheaper at about $62,600 versus $76,600 for A), then dividing by its 4-year life. Present worth is only valid when the lives are equal; use EUAC or a common life.