Effective Stress with a Water Table Example
Find the vertical effective stress in a clay layer below the water table, the most common FE geotechnical stress calculation.
Problem
A site has 6 m of sand over 4 m of clay, resting on rock. The water table is 3 m below the ground surface, and the water pressure is hydrostatic. The sand above the water table has a moist unit weight of 17 kN/m³; the sand below the water table has a saturated unit weight of 20 kN/m³. The clay has a saturated unit weight of 18 kN/m³. Use kN/m³.
The vertical effective stress at point A, at the middle of the clay layer (8 m below the ground surface), is most nearly:
- 68.5 kPa
- 98.0 kPa
- 107.0 kPa
- 147.0 kPa
Answer
Show stepsHide steps
Given
- Sand 0–3 m (above WT):
- Sand 3–6 m (below WT):
- Clay 6–10 m:
- Water table at 3 m; point A at 8 m (5 m below WT)
Method 1, step 1: Total vertical stress at A
Add the weight of every layer above A (3 m of moist sand, 3 m of saturated sand, 2 m of clay):
Method 1, step 2: Pore water pressure at A
The water column above A is measured from the water table, not the ground surface:
Method 1, step 3: Effective stress
Method 2 (check): Buoyant unit weights
Below the water table, the soil skeleton feels only its submerged (buoyant) weight, . Above the water table, use the moist unit weight as is:
Both methods give the same result.
Concept
Soil carries load through grain-to-grain contact. The effective stress is the part of the total vertical stress carried by the soil skeleton; the rest is carried by the pore water. Effective stress controls strength and settlement.
- Total stress: add up unit weight times thickness for every layer above the point.
- Pore pressure (hydrostatic): water unit weight times depth below the water table.
- Above the water table use the moist unit weight; below it use the saturated unit weight.
See the Effective Stress and phase-relationship equations in the Geotechnical section of the NCEES FE Reference Handbook.
Key Formulas
Notation: = total vertical stress, = pore water pressure, = effective stress, = depth below the water table, = buoyant unit weight.
Common Mistakes
- (A) 68.5 kPa: measuring the water column from the ground surface (u = 9.81 × 8 = 78.5 kPa) instead of from the water table.
- (C) 107.0 kPa: using the saturated unit weight (20 kN/m³) for the sand above the water table.
- (D) 147.0 kPa: reporting the total stress and forgetting to subtract the pore water pressure.